Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

Latest post 01-30-2009 0:15 by petty026. 9 replies.
  • 07-18-2008 11:13

    Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

    I've been using kbb.com and other sites to research these two cars and am having a really hard time figuring out what to do.  From a features standpoint, they seem really similar.  The Prius is arguably more hip (and the Honda a little more -- um -- boring) but both seem pretty equal.

    So...what do I do?  I'm not looking for random uninformed comments...I'm looking for feedback from owners or people who have driven these cars extensively.  Any REAL owners out there who can help?

  • 07-25-2008 14:46 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

    High Tech Personal Opinion: Wait for the right car! don't buy the car if you don't like even 5% 

     Toyota Prius :
    ----------------------

    Pros: Unbeatable fuel economy, space-efficient body style with ample passenger and cargo space, comfy ride, borderline luxurious interior, easy-to-turn steering.
    Cons:

    Unacceptable space for drivers of above-average height, easy-to-turn steering is too uncommunicative for many, non-eco-friendly leather upholstery

    Honda Civic:
    --------------

    Pros: Fuel-efficient and peppy engine, user-friendly controls, roomy interior, large trunk.
    Cons: Controversial gauge design, rear-folding seat not split.

    And if you buy Prius then here is my detail experience:


    There are certain things you notice when driving through Los Angeles. The inexplicable traffic jams. The blonde bombshells in BMWs. The way highway on-ramps are frequently not in the same place as the off-ramp. Or, you may notice that there's a Toyota Prius everywhere you look. Californians often credit themselves with being "ahead" of the rest of the country when it comes to basically everything, while the rest of the country considers California to have an inflated sense of self-worth. There is limited truth to both. However, the 2008 Toyota Prius is certainly a part of such a debate, and there are a number of questions that should be asked before taking one of these quintessential hybrids home. First, is there something meatier at the heart of Prius mania than just a green fad fueled by poseur environmentalists trying to make a statement to friends, neighbors and passing strangers? Also, we all know the Prius gets excellent gas mileage, but what does that fuel savings really mean to your wallet and the environment given its price tag and non-hybrid competitors? Finally, is it really a good car, or have 1 million American motorists been duped by a questionable green message? Well, the simple answer is that the Prius is actually quite good. Given its superb interior packaging, ample features list and unbeatable fuel economy, the Prius was designed to be the epitome of practical, head-over-heart automotive choices. Its driving experience will never excite and its styling is hardly what most folks would deem attractive, yet for those who view cars as simple transportation devices, it's easy to recommend the Prius. It is priced similar to traditional midsize sedans, while sacrificing some performance and standard features in favor of better fuel economy and greater interior/cargo space. Plus, you can equip a Prius to near-luxury levels, as our test car was.Performance

    At the heart of the Toyota Prius is a revolutionary hybrid drivetrain that marries a 1.5-liter four-cylinder gasoline engine to two electric motors (one to help drive the front wheels and the other to recharge the nickel-metal hydride battery pack). This setup allows for the gasoline and electric motors to work by themselves or in concert with each other depending on the driving situation. When creeping along in traffic or under light acceleration, the Prius uses only its electric system, which is where a majority of fuel savings comes from.

    When speeds and acceleration demands increase, the gas engine kicks in with a noticeable but not distracting shudder. Attached to a continuously variable transmission of sorts, the gas engine can sound a bit gnarly when pushed, as it's hardly a power champion with 76 horsepower and 82 pound-feet of torque. The electric motor's additional 67 hp and 295 lb-ft of torque pitches in, but the Prius is still only capable of a 0-60-mph sprint of 10.4 seconds. Given the leisurely nature of most motorists' acceleration habits, many will only occasionally notice the Prius' power deficit.

    Many will also turn a blind eye given the unbeatable fuel economy this hybrid returns. The EPA estimates a return of 48 mpg city/45 mpg highway and 46 mpg combined. We conducted an extended fuel economy test-drive with this particular Prius and were actually able to best the EPA's numbers. Driving in and around Las Vegas, we achieved a truly impressive 52 mpg. On the highway between Vegas and Los Angeles, the Prius still managed 47 mpg, despite its relying less on the electric motor. In both tests, we did nothing fancy to achieve these numbers — although knowing how to maximize all-electric acceleration will certainly improve your own results.

    While there's much to discuss about the Prius' powertrain, the rest of the driving experience will leave you cold (if you care). The electric-power steering system is lifeless and transmits practically no information to the driver's hands. It is, however, tremendously easy to turn at any speed, which has proven particularly popular with senior citizens. The ride is also tuned for maximum comfort and cossets passengers well from road imperfections.

    Comfort

    Everyone should be happy with the ride comfort, which provides a buttoned-down, big-car feel to a lightweight car. Compared to fuel-efficient compact cars, the Prius feels almost Lincoln-like as it softly damps road imperfections. The Toyota is also very quiet thanks to ample sound-deadening materials and an exterior designed to slice through the air like a light saber through tofu. Around town, the electric motors' muted hum also contributes to a very serene cabin.

    Function

    Our fully loaded test car came with a navigation system, but all Priuses are equipped with a touchscreen interface that controls nearly all stereo and climate functions. Thankfully, the steering wheel has an inordinate amount of secondary controls to make more frequently used functions like temperature and radio presets quick and easy to change. The steering wheel also houses controls for the Bluetooth phone connection and the navigation system's voice commands. The latter work OK, but they take too long to use as there is no way to turn off the car's command prompts and parrotlike command confirmation.

    In total, however, the 2008 Toyota Prius is a marvel of practical functionality thanks to its space-efficient body style. A rear- and front-facing child seat was easy to install thanks to the huge backseat and generous rear door opening. The 14.4-cubic-foot hatchback trunk easily swallows golf clubs and/or a fair share of luggage, while the 60/40-split-folding rear seat combines with the Prius' tall roof line to allow for a truly amazing amount of cargo space. We managed to fit in three men's weekend luggage, several paper grocery bags, 2 gallons of water and two guitars (plus the three men).

    Design/Fit and Finish

    The Prius often makes you feel like you're driving the Epcot Center Car of Tomorrow. The dash is wide and flat, with the touchscreen jutting up in a rectangular pod. The car starts with the push of a button, but there's no engine start-up noise, just an instrument panel light that says "Ready." That all-digital instrument panel resides just below the windshield, almost like a head-up display. The stubby shifter juts out of the dash and operates like something made by Atari. In other words, it's weird, but you quickly get used to it.

    Interior quality is decent for this price point, with good materials and tight fit and finish. Most Priuses come with a nice velourlike upholstery, but our test car came with leather. It's nice leather, but if you really care about the environment, you'll skip this option: The cattle industry is one of the biggest producers of greenhouse gases, as well as a significant cause of land and water degradation.

    Who Should Buy This Vehicle

    Those who do not prioritize speed or driving excitement. If you're just looking for practical, comfortable and fuel-efficient transportation that can be luxuriously equipped, the 2008 Toyota Prius is a very wise choice.

    Filed under:
  • 08-18-2008 9:47 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

    I bought a Civic hybrid about a month and a half ago. So far, no complaints. It handles well, is roomy, and has more pep than I had expected.

    I've also driven a Prius. I'd have to say that the biggest differences that I've found are:

    • The engine shut down at stops seems/feels much less pronounced in the Civic. It happens, but doesn't seem quite as shocking as it did in my experience with the Prius.
    • The Civic also seemed to have more pep when taking off at a green light.
    • When I was pricing them out, the deal on the Civic was sweeter...there was a low APR special going on.

    I really liked the Prius too. There's definitely something to be said about its unique style. Somehow it seemed "more like a hybrid" than the Civic does.  But when all was said and done, I felt like I got more bang for my buck with the Civic.

     

  • 08-20-2008 13:38 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

     These are some really great points, gettinggreener. What is your average mpg, and how often do you have to fill up your gas tank?

  • 08-20-2008 14:09 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

    So far, I've been getting about 46 mpg, but I do mostly highway driving. And I do a lot of highway driving right now, so I still have to fill up quite often. But it would be significantly more often had I kept my old car.

     

  • 08-23-2008 20:33 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

     I like the exterior design of Honda Civic

  • 08-24-2008 20:25 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

    Hello,  I purchased my Honda Civic Hybrid in 2005.  I really like it.  Great to have to fill up only every two weeks.  I get about 42 mpg.  Of course, I've always bought Hondas so there was no question between the Honda and the Prius when I bought my hybrid.   I've really come to like that the engine shuts down at red lights, in line at the drive through, etc.  Just nice to know I'm not burning fuel at $4.00 a gallon just sitting.  Good luck deciding. . .

  • 08-25-2008 9:50 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

     Thanks for sharing, Jane! I wonder if they still issue carpool permission to hybrid or not. with my commute situation, that is critical. If not, I will have to look for a used prius with the carpool sticker.

     

  • 09-14-2008 6:37 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

     hello

     

    I have sold and driven both. If safty is an issue buy the Honda, Prius has a 2 star rear crash test, very poor.

    Prius wins the bells and whistles by far. I like the hatch back options it provides also. I would buy me a prius, no I have bought and would again buy a Camry Hybrid, they are AWESOME.

    I now represent Cadillac. Waiting on the new SUV's to get here. Huge Vehicle and 25MPG!

     

  • 01-30-2009 0:15 In reply to

    Re: Which to buy...Toyota Prius or Honda Civic Hybrid?

    CADILLAC RIC:

     hello

     

    I have sold and driven both. If safty is an issue buy the Honda, Prius has a 2 star rear crash test, very poor.

    Prius wins the bells and whistles by far. I like the hatch back options it provides also and their car covers discount.  I would buy me a prius, no I have bought and would again buy a Camry Hybrid, they are AWESOME.

    I now represent Cadillac. Waiting on the new SUV's to get here. Huge Vehicle and 25MPG!

    I like them both.. and it's confusing to choose between the two. I've been a fan of Prius ever since it came, and it's larger than the civic. But, the civic looks sophisticated more.

     

     

Page 1 of 1 (10 items) | RSS